Can You Plant a Tree in the Same Spot Where a Tree Was Removed?

Planting New Tree

After you have a tree removed from your property, you may want to fill the void left behind. Planting a new tree in its place is one option, but you must be vigilant to avoid having to cut down the new tree due to disease or insects. Here are some other factors to consider before deciding to replant a tree.

Clearing the Stump

When you hire tree removal specialists, you will have to decide whether to have the stump removed as well. Reasons to get rid of it include:

  • Attracts insects – As stumps rot, they can attract ants, beetles, termites and other pests.
  • Causes new tree growth – Leaving the stump behind can cause new sprouts to shoot up and grow into trees, which can potentially leach nutrients from nearby plants.
  • Hazardous – Stumps pose a tripping hazard, especially if you have kids. Stumps can also damage your lawn mower if you accidentally hit one while cutting the grass.
  • Unattractive – If you are particular about the aesthetics of your landscaping, you will want to remove the stump, as it is an eyesore.

If you want to replant, you will need to have the stump removed. Afterward, you may be left with a hole filled with sawdust and roots from the old tree. You will need to remove these to provide a healthy environment for the new tree to grow.

As the remains of the stump decompose, they can deplete nitrogen from the soil. Before deciding to replant, you should have the soil tested. You may need to add lime to reduce the acidity.

Choosing the Right Tree to Replant

If your old tree was removed due to disease, the pathogen could be lingering in the soil, which can lead to replant disease in a new tree. Replant disease stunts growth and can kill many tree species, including:

  • Apple
  • Cherry
  • Citrus
  • Pear
  • Pine
  • Spruce

To prevent replant disease, you must remove the entire dead tree, including its roots and stump. Replace the contaminated soil with fresh soil and sterilize any gardening tools that came in contact with the diseased tree.

Certain species are prone to disease or insects, so if you want to help your new tree live a long time, you should choose a hardy variety, such as:

  • Chilean wine palm
  • Macedonian pine
  • Mondell pine
  • Red flowering gum
  • Siberian pea
  • Star acacia

You should also consider the climate in your area before deciding which tree to plant. Georgia, for example, ranges from zones 6a to 9a on the U.S. Department of Agriculture’s (USDA) plant hardiness zone map. If you live in the Atlanta area, this means you should buy a tree that can withstand temperatures as low as 10 degrees.

It can be tempting to replant a tree soon after removing an old one to bring new life to your yard. However, it may be easier to prepare the planting site after a year or so because the roots will have had time to decompose.

Professional Tree Care Service in Atlanta

If you are considering replanting because you have a diseased or insect-ridden tree, it is important to work with specialists who have the expertise to safely remove or preserve your tree to protect your property and the health of your landscaping.

Gunnison Tree Specialists has handled residential tree issues for nearly 20 years and we can help find the solution that is right for you – whether it is a tree removal, pruning service or disease management. Call 404-386-3333 or contact us online for a free quote.


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *